← Chapter companions

TRY IT YOURSELF

The Devil’s Advocate

A useful challenge can make a good idea stronger. Give ChatGPT the idea, ask it to argue against it and use what it finds to improve your next move.

Your starting prompt

Act as devil’s advocate for this idea: [explain the idea, who it serves and how it would work]. Challenge my assumptions. Give me the strongest arguments against it, including a practical hurdle I may have missed. Explain which points matter most and what evidence would change your view. Then help me improve the idea and choose one inexpensive test before I commit.
Download worksheet

Put it to work

  1. Explain what you want to do and why.
  2. Ask for the strongest case against it, including anything you have overlooked.
  3. Choose the objection that could change your decision.
  4. Turn it into a specific improvement or a small test.

Your notes

My idea:

The assumption I want to test:

The most useful objection:

What I will change:

My next test:

A reusable exercise adapted from the chapter. Replace the bracketed details with your own.

Try the approach with Nathan in the live course →